Framing is Crucial
Last week on this blog, I said that, in order to win the voters’ trust.
Democrats must focus on passing laws that help the people who voted for them in
obvious ways that those voters can see. I said,
The Democrats must recognize that they were not elected because American voters had fallen in love with the Democratic Party. The Democrats won because the voters felt betrayed by Mr. Trump.
The voters don't really trust the Democrats, but now, they have an opportunity to win the voters’ trust,
and the opportunity should not be wasted.
Enacting – or at least trying to enact – policies that improve the lives of working Americans will help, but it will not be enough. The Democrats must also control the framing of the public discussion.
Framing is the process of setting the context of the discussion of a political
issue. Effective framing determines the way that voters see an issue. A
political proposal can succeed if it is framed in a way that draws political
support, or it can fail because it is framed in a way that alienates the voters.
Republicans are very good at framing issues in a way that gives them an
advantage, but Democrats do poorly at framing.
Democrats Need Help With Framing
Democrats do poorly at framing because, the members of the left wing of the
party, which has most of the party’s good ideas, like to present their ideas as revolutionary improvements
in our society although their proposals are far from radical. They are well
within the main stream of American politics, but the voters and many politicians reject those proposals because of their supposed - and entirely fictitious - radicalism.
The Republicans are happy to amplify and emphasize the radical quality of Democrats' proposals, and by doing so, effectively turn millions of voters against those proposals. Most Americans are not looking for a revolution. They are only looking for a solution to a problem in a system that they see as fundamentally good.
So, the Democrats' best ideas need to be reframed to make their moderate character obvious
to everyone. The proposals were never really revolutionary, but Some Republicans have already begun to characterize them as communistic. Other Republicans are trying to paint moderate demands for reasonable fairness as dangerously radical proposals. If Democrats allow that framing to dominate the
discussion, their proposals will fail for lack of support from voters and
politicians. A moderate framing might just give the Democrats a chance to turn
their proposals into laws. What would such a framing look like?
Moderate Framing
Use a Narrow Problem-Solving Approach
One element of moderate framing is a narrow, problem-solving
approach that avoids fundamental criticism of our society and economy.
This approach says that, while our economy and society are fundamentally just
and sound, a problem has arisen that we need to solve. For example, many of us
know that Americans pay more for healthcare than the people of any other
industrial country in the world. We know, too, that our system produces
mediocre health outcomes at best. Democrats can say that this problem has come about
because greedy people have taken advantage of our open economy to build a healthcare system that brings them enormous profits at the expense of the rest
of us. For the benefit of all of us, we need modify the system so that it
provides better care at a cost that we can afford.
Propose No Major Break With Our Existing System
A second element of moderate framing is to emphasize the
fact that the Democrats' solution does not represent a major break with our existing
system. The party needs to argue that the solution it is proposing is really an
extension of the system that we already have. Medicare for All can easily be portrayed such an
extension. Our existing Medicare program is one of our most successful
programs. It provides affordable healthcare to millions of senior citizens. All that the Democrats are proposing is to extend it to cover the rest of us. Why should seniors be
the only people with affordable healthcare? Why shouldn’t all of us have it? No
major change to the system is needed. We just need to extend it to cover us
all.
Emphasize Reducing Cost and Putting Money in People's Pockets
A third element of moderate framing is to show that a proposed solution would save money for American businesses and put more money in
everyone's pocket. Americans are stressed economically, and Democrats can address
their suffering by pointing out how a Democratic proposal would put money in their
pockets. In the case of Medicare for All, the case could begin with the idea
that the taxes they would have to pay would be less than the health insurance
premiums that they are now paying. As a result, people would have more money to
spend on other things. In addition, Medicare for All would relieve businesses
of the cost of health insurance. That would allow the businesses to raise
salaries and also to hire more workers.
This argument is particularly important for persuading
so-called "centrist" Democrats. Today's Democratic Party is not a
working-class party. It is the party
of the patrimonial middle class, and the members
of that class do not need Medicare for All because they already have decent
health insurance. In order to get Congress to pass Medicare for All,
it's supporters will have to persuade the centrist Democrats as well as some
Republicans that Medicare for All would benefit everyone and not just people
who lack health insurance today.
Make a Moral Case Based on Traditional American Values
A final element of moderate framing involves showing that
the moral case for our proposal comes from traditional, American values. James
Talarico’s victory in Texas has shown that framing issues in traditional ways resonates with many voters. His approach is religious, but secular approaches are also available. One possible secular approach
would be to emphasize American ideas of fairness. A system that
was designed to make money for its designers while squeezing the rest of us
financially is fundamentally unfair. It is not consistent with our idea of
fairness. A system that provides affordable care for some people but not for
others is incompatible with American values.
Repeat the Framing Over and Over and Over and Over
The key to successful framing is to repeat it over and over
and over. Democrats can't just make their point and assume that people will understand. They have to repeat their framing of an issue over and over. They have to repeat it in different
ways every day. They have to use TV ads, blog posts, Instagram posts, FB posts,
newspaper and magazine articles, speeches and interviews. They must repeat the framing so often
that it becomes part of the accepted view of the topic. Republicans are very
good at this. Democrats have to learn.
They should start now.
You've been reading your George Lakoff! These are great examples and we all need to learn to talk this way if we are to use this 1st step to get us past this terrible point in our history.
ReplyDeleteThank you!
Thank you for the encouragement.
Delete